AMERICAN EAGLE OUTFITTERS INC (AEO) — Insider Trading

AI-Powered SEC Filing Analysis

Latest Insider Trading Filed: 2026-04-28

Key Insights

Director Deborah A. Henretta acquired 612 share units through dividend equivalent rights on 04/24/2026, bringing her total beneficial ownership to 88,205 share units, indicating continued accumulation of company equity.
The acquisition was executed through a dividend reinvestment mechanism rather than open market purchase, suggesting passive income reinvestment rather than active voting confidence in the stock price.
As a director-level insider, Henretta's modest acquisition of dividend equivalents represents routine compensation activity rather than a significant bullish signal of insider conviction about future stock performance.

Want the newest filings?

This analysis covers the filing from 2026-04-28. New 10-K, 10-Q and 8-K filings are analyzed the moment they are released — exclusively in the app.

Download on the App Store Open in app →

Earlier Insider Trading filings

Filed: 2026-04-28

Executive Chairman & CEO Jay L. Schottenstein acquired 1,781 dividend equivalent rights on April 24, 2026, which are economic equivalents of common stock and will vest with underlying RSUs, indicating ongoing equity compensation tied to company performance.
The reporting person beneficially owns 6,828 derivative securities (dividend equivalent rights) following this transaction, demonstrating significant equity stake alignment with shareholder interests.
This is a routine dividend equivalent right accrual on restricted stock units rather than discretionary open-market buying, suggesting compensation structure rather than bullish insider sentiment about near-term stock performance.

Filed: 2026-04-28

Executive Michael A. Mathias, EVP and CFO, received 350 dividend equivalent rights (DERs) accrued on restricted stock units on 04/24/2026, representing automatic dividend equivalents tied to existing RSU compensation rather than discretionary insider buying.
The transaction reflects routine compensation administration with DERs converting to 350 shares of common stock value, bringing total beneficial ownership of derivative securities to 1,344 shares, indicating standard executive retention mechanisms rather than market conviction.
No actual stock purchase or sale occurred; this filing documents non-cash compensation accrual, which is a passive adjustment to existing equity awards and provides limited signal regarding insider sentiment about AEO's stock valuation or business outlook.

Filed: 2026-04-28

James H. Keefer Jr., SVP Controller & CAO, received 136 dividend equivalent rights on RSUs that accrued on 04/24/2026, indicating ongoing equity compensation tied to restricted stock units vesting.
The reporting person beneficially owns 534 derivative securities (dividend equivalent rights) in direct form, suggesting meaningful equity stake alignment with company performance.
This is a routine dividend equivalent rights accrual on restricted stock units rather than discretionary insider buying or selling, reflecting standard compensation plan mechanics rather than market sentiment signals.

Filed: 2026-04-28

Director Chandrasekaran Sujatha acquired 208 share units through dividend equivalent rights accrued on previously awarded units, representing a routine compensation distribution rather than discretionary insider buying.
The transaction reflects director compensation practices typical of board service, with share units that only vest upon termination of service, indicating long-term alignment with the company but no new cash investment.
Total beneficial ownership stands at 30,024 share units following this transaction, suggesting meaningful accumulated equity stake from ongoing director compensation over time.

Filed: 2026-04-28

Beth M. Henke, EVP & Chief Legal Officer, acquired 177 dividend equivalent rights (DERs) on 04/24/2026 through accrual on restricted stock units, now holding 555 total DERs, indicating ongoing equity compensation as part of executive retention.
The transaction represents automatic dividend equivalent accrual rather than discretionary insider buying, which provides minimal insight into management's confidence in AEO's stock price direction.
As a senior executive officer, Henke's continued equity stake demonstrates alignment with shareholders, though the small magnitude and passive nature of the acquisition suggests routine compensation administration rather than a significant conviction signal.

Filed: 2026-04-28

Jennifer M. Foyle, Global Brand President of Aerie, acquired 915 dividend equivalent rights on 04/24/2026, which are economically equivalent to common stock and accrue on restricted stock units, indicating continued equity compensation tied to RSU vesting.
The transaction represents a routine dividend equivalent right accrual rather than a discretionary open-market purchase, suggesting this is automatic compensation reinvestment rather than a signal of insider confidence in the stock price.
Foyle now beneficially owns 3,666 derivative securities (dividend equivalent rights), demonstrating meaningful equity stake alignment with the Aerie brand division, though the small transaction size ($0 exercise price) is typical for dividend equivalents.

Filed: 2026-04-28

EVP-CHRO Marisa Baldwin acquired 192 dividend equivalent rights (DERs) on 04/24/2026, which are economic equivalents of common stock and accrue on previously awarded RSUs, indicating continued equity compensation tied to restricted stock vesting.
Baldwin now beneficially owns 715 total derivative securities (DERs), suggesting meaningful long-term equity incentive alignment with company performance, though this represents an accumulation of dividend equivalents rather than new option grants.
The transaction is a routine administrative accrual of dividend rights on existing RSU awards rather than discretionary insider buying, limiting inference about executive confidence in near-term stock performance.

Filed: 2026-04-08

The reporting person, Cary D. McMillan, sold 2,887 shares of American Eagle Outfitters Inc. (AEO) on April 6, 2026 at an average price of $17.225 per share.
This sale represents the entirety of McMillan's direct beneficial ownership in AEO, indicating a complete divestment of his position.
Insider selling activity can signal a bearish sentiment or loss of confidence in the company's prospects, which investors may want to further investigate.

Filed: 2026-04-08

Noel Joseph Spiegel, a director at American Eagle Outfitters, has sold 2,887 shares of the company's common stock at a price of $17.32 per share.
This transaction represents a decrease in Spiegel's direct beneficial ownership of American Eagle Outfitters shares, which now stands at 0.
Insider selling can be a signal of management's outlook on the company's future performance, and investors should monitor any significant changes in insider ownership.

Filed: 2026-04-06

Jay L. Schottenstein, the Executive Chairman and CEO, exercised 79,361 stock options and sold 31,610 shares, retaining a direct ownership of 2,272,971 shares.
Schottenstein has additional indirect ownership of 2,611,235 shares through Schottenstein SEI, LLC and 2,971,202 shares through SEI, Inc., as well as 6,386,995 shares held in trusts.
The transaction appears to be part of Schottenstein's ongoing portfolio management, as he maintains a substantial ownership stake in the company as a key executive and insider.

Filed: 2026-04-06

Marisa Baldwin, the EVP - CHRO of American Eagle Outfitters, exercised 8,228 stock options and 7,886 restricted stock units in early April 2026, indicating her continued commitment to the company.
Baldwin sold 4,201 shares, likely for tax purposes, but still holds a significant direct ownership stake of 52,037 shares in the company.
The insider transaction shows that key leadership remains bullish on American Eagle Outfitters' future prospects, as evidenced by their willingness to hold onto a large portion of their equity compensation.

Filed: 2026-04-06

Jennifer M. Foyle, the Global Brand President of aerie, has exercised 40,849 stock options and disposed of 22,591 shares, indicating an ongoing pattern of insider selling.
Foyle still holds a substantial direct ownership of 316,337 shares, suggesting she maintains a significant stake in the company.
The timing of the transactions, with the options exercise and share sale occurring on the same day, April 2, 2026, suggests she may be actively managing her position.

Filed: 2026-04-06

Beth M. Henke, the EVP and Chief Legal Officer of American Eagle Outfitters, acquired 6,265 shares of common stock through the vesting of restricted stock units (RSUs) and dividend equivalent rights.
Henke also sold 1,911 shares to cover tax withholding obligations, leaving her with a total of 21,529 shares directly owned.
The filing indicates that Henke continues to hold a significant number of RSUs, suggesting her ongoing commitment to the company.

Filed: 2026-04-06

James H. Keefer Jr., the SVP, Controller & CAO of American Eagle Outfitters, acquired 6,265 shares of the company's common stock through the vesting of restricted stock units (RSUs) and dividend equivalent rights.
Keefer also sold 1,785 shares of common stock, likely for tax withholding purposes, resulting in a net increase of 4,480 shares in his direct beneficial ownership.
The vesting of RSUs and dividend equivalent rights suggests that Keefer's compensation is aligned with the company's long-term performance, which could be viewed positively by investors.

Filed: 2026-04-06

Michael Mathias, the EVP and CFO of American Eagle Outfitters, acquired 15,622 shares through an equity award and disposed of 6,913 shares to cover tax withholding, indicating continued executive ownership in the company.
Mathias also holds 1,100 shares in his spouse's IRA, suggesting additional indirect ownership in the company.
The vesting of restricted stock units and dividend equivalent rights indicates ongoing long-term incentive compensation for the executive, aligning his interests with shareholders.

Filed: 2026-04-01

Marisa Baldwin, an Executive Vice President and Chief Human Resources Officer of American Eagle Outfitters, exercised 4,138 stock options and disposed of 2,113 shares through a stock sale, indicating an ongoing engagement and alignment of management's interests with those of shareholders.
The transaction involved a combination of option exercises and share sales, suggesting a balanced approach to managing her equity position in the company.
The timing of the transaction, occurring in late March 2026, may provide insight into management's view of the company's near-term prospects and performance.

Filed: 2026-04-01

The reporting person, Jay L. Schottenstein, who is the Executive Chairman and CEO of American Eagle Outfitters, acquired 45,767 shares of the company's common stock through the vesting of restricted stock units (RSUs).
Schottenstein also disposed of 18,229 shares of common stock through a 'net settlement' transaction, where shares were withheld to cover tax obligations.
Schottenstein continues to hold a substantial beneficial ownership position in the company, with over 6.3 million shares owned directly and indirectly through various trusts and entities.

Filed: 2026-04-01

Michael A. Mathias, the EVP and CFO of American Eagle Outfitters, exercised 8,824 stock options and sold 3,904 shares, retaining 129,397 shares directly owned and an additional 1,100 shares owned indirectly through his spouse's IRA account.
The transaction was part of a 10b5-1 trading plan, indicating pre-planned and systematic insider selling, which may signal confidence in the company's future performance.
The reported transaction represents a modest change in Mathias's overall equity position, suggesting this was a routine portfolio rebalancing rather than a significant change in his outlook on the company.

Filed: 2026-04-01

James H. Keefer Jr., the SVP, Controller & CAO of American Eagle Outfitters, exercised 4,138 stock options and sold 1,179 shares of the company's common stock on March 30, 2026.
The transaction represents a partial liquidation of Keefer's position, as his beneficial ownership decreased from 25,185 to 24,006 shares following the reported transaction.
The exercise price of the stock options was $0.00, indicating they were part of Keefer's compensation package, and the sale price of the 1,179 shares was $16.09 per share.

Important Information

AI-generated analysis is for informational purposes only. Always read original SEC filings and consult with qualified professionals before making investment decisions.