CREDIT ACCEPTANCE CORP (CACC) — Insider Trading

AI-Powered SEC Filing Analysis

Latest Insider Trading Filed: 2026-05-08

Key Insights

Chief Legal Officer Erin J. Kerber executed a net sale of 1,753 shares on 05/06/2026, with total dispositions of 1,753 shares across multiple tranches at prices ranging from $550.00 to $559.37, indicating a net selling position during this trading window.
The officer simultaneously acquired 1,753 shares at $333.94 through option exercise (dated 12/30/2024-12/30/2026 expiration), suggesting a structured 10b5-1 trading plan that involved exercising options and immediately selling shares for profit-taking.
Kerber holds 25,710.7 shares directly plus 240 shares indirectly through a 401(k) plan, demonstrating meaningful personal investment in CACC, though the net selling activity suggests confidence in valuation levels rather than conviction in near-term upside.
The filing shows significant unexercised options remaining (15,500 shares at $454.11 expiring 06/28/2027), indicating compensation structure but no immediate exercise plans, which is neutral for near-term insider sentiment.

Want the newest filings?

This analysis covers the filing from 2026-05-08. New 10-K, 10-Q and 8-K filings are analyzed the moment they are released — exclusively in the app.

Download on the App Store Open in app →

Earlier Insider Trading filings

Filed: 2026-05-08

Chief Transformation Officer Nicholas Elliott executed a net sale of 1,608 shares on 05/06/2026, selling across 6 tranches at prices ranging from $550.24 to $557.09, while simultaneously acquiring 1,672 shares at $333.94, suggesting a stock option exercise followed by partial profit-taking.
The officer's beneficial ownership decreased from approximately 22,569 to 20,897 direct shares after these transactions, indicating a net reduction in direct holdings despite the option exercise, which could signal confidence concerns or portfolio rebalancing.
The price progression of sales from $550 to $557 across multiple tranches suggests disciplined selling in an uptrend, consistent with a pre-planned Rule 10b5-1 trading plan as noted in the filing checkbox, reducing the appearance of opportunistic selling.
Elliott maintains 322 additional shares indirectly through the company's 401(k) plan, showing some ongoing confidence in CACC despite the net reduction in direct holdings.

Filed: 2026-05-08

Chief People Officer Wendy A. Rummler executed a net sell transaction, disposing of 2,048 shares (1,625 + 126 + 88 + 177 + 17 + 19 + 4 + 12) while acquiring 2,068 shares, resulting in minimal net position change of +20 shares at an average acquisition price of $333.94.
The selling activity occurred across multiple price points ranging from $550-$565, suggesting tactical profit-taking or portfolio rebalancing rather than a single coordinated sale, with weighted average sale prices significantly higher than the acquisition price of $333.94.
Rummler maintains substantial beneficial ownership of approximately 19,559 directly-held shares plus 5,069.5 shares held indirectly through trusts (Kevin Rummler Revocable Trust: 2,704 shares and Wendy A. Rummler Revocable Trust: 2,365.5 shares), totaling approximately 24,628.6 shares.
The transaction was executed pursuant to a Rule 10b5-1 trading plan, indicating pre-planned, non-discretionary trading that minimizes concerns about timing based on non-public information.

Filed: 2026-05-08

CFO Jay D. Martin exercised 1,439 employee stock options at $333.94 on 05/06/2026, suggesting confidence in the company's valuation and future prospects despite subsequent selling activity.
Martin sold a total of 1,479 shares across multiple transactions on the same day at prices ranging from $550.00 to $559.37, reducing his beneficial ownership from 27,402 to 25,963 shares, indicating a potential rebalancing or profit-taking strategy.
The transaction was executed under a Rule 10b5-1 trading plan, indicating pre-planned systematic selling rather than opportunistic trading, which reduces concerns about negative insider sentiment.
Martin maintains substantial direct ownership of 25,963 shares post-transaction, demonstrating continued significant financial alignment with shareholder interests despite the sale activity.

Filed: 2026-05-08

Chief Operating Officer Jonathan Lum executed a net sell transaction on 05/06/2026, purchasing 4,000 shares at $333.94 and immediately selling the same 4,000 shares at $550, realizing a $64,240 gain (64% spread) in a single day.
The insider's beneficial ownership decreased from 35,608.6 to 31,608.6 shares following the transaction, indicating a net reduction of 4,000 shares and a reduction in his direct stake in the company.
The transaction was executed pursuant to a Rule 10b5-1 trading plan (indicated by the checked box), suggesting this was pre-planned trading rather than opportunistic market timing, which reduces concerns about negative insider sentiment.
The COO still maintains 24,500 employee stock options exercisable through 12/30/2026, indicating ongoing equity compensation alignment with shareholder interests despite the recent share disposition.

Filed: 2026-05-08

Director Kenneth Booth executed a Rule 10b5-1 trading plan, purchasing 4,000 shares at $333.94 on 05/06/2026 and simultaneously selling 4,000 shares at $554, realizing a $880,240 gain on the transaction.
The significant price differential between the buy ($333.94) and sell ($554) suggests these may represent different security classes or the insider is executing a pre-planned trading strategy rather than expressing directional conviction about the stock.
Booth's beneficial ownership remains substantial at approximately 22,831.9 shares after the transaction, with an additional 110,000 shares underlying employee stock options expiring in 2028, indicating continued material insider commitment.
The filing of a Rule 10b5-1 plan indicates the insider established this trading arrangement in advance, suggesting structured, compliant capital management rather than opportunistic market timing based on non-public information.

Filed: 2026-04-22

Director Kenneth Booth executed a Rule 10b5-1 trading plan, purchasing 4,000 shares at $333.94 on 04/20/2026 and immediately selling the same 4,000 shares at $534 on the same day, locking in a $200.06 per-share profit ($800,240 total gain).
The same-day buy-sell transaction suggests predetermined profit-taking rather than conviction in holding the stock; the significant spread indicates either prior planned sales or opportunistic trading under a pre-established plan.
Booth's beneficial ownership declined from approximately 26,832 shares to 22,832 shares after the sale, reducing his direct stake in CACC despite holding director and 10% owner positions.
Two employee stock options remain outstanding totaling 114,000 shares (4,000 at $333.94 expiring 12/30/2026 and 110,000 at $390.39 expiring 01/31/2028), providing significant additional leverage to company equity.

Filed: 2026-04-22

COO Jonathan Lum executed a net sell of 3,000 shares (sold at $535 after acquiring at $333.94), realizing a significant profit of approximately $603,000, suggesting confidence in current valuation but also taking gains.
The transaction was made pursuant to a Rule 10b5-1 trading plan, indicating this was pre-arranged and not based on recent material non-public information, which reduces negative insider selling implications.
Following the reported transactions, Lum maintains 31,608.6 shares of direct beneficial ownership plus 28,500 in-the-money options, demonstrating substantial continued equity stake in CACC despite the recent sale.

Filed: 2026-04-21

Chief People Officer Wendy A. Rummler executed a net sale of 4,062 shares on 04/17/2026, with three separate sell transactions totaling 4,062 shares at prices ranging from $525.00 to $527.72, while simultaneously acquiring 4,062 shares at $333.94 per share through what appears to be option exercise.
The filing indicates use of a Rule 10b5-1 trading plan, suggesting pre-planned, non-discretionary sales that reduce concerns about negative insider sentiment, though the net selling activity still represents a modest reduction in direct beneficial ownership.
Rummler maintains significant beneficial ownership of approximately 19,547 shares directly, plus indirect holdings of approximately 5,069.5 shares through two revocable trusts, demonstrating continued confidence in CACC despite the recent sales activity.

Filed: 2026-04-21

Chief Marketing and Product Officer Andrew K. Rostami acquired 473.5 shares of CACC stock at $527.56 per share on April 18, 2026, through vesting of restricted stock units, indicating continued equity compensation and insider confidence in the company.
Rostami received 16,000 stock options with an exercise price of $585.93, expiring April 18, 2028, demonstrating the company's use of long-term incentive compensation to retain senior management.
The insider's total beneficial ownership increased to 23,090.9 shares following the transaction, with shares withheld for tax obligations on RSU settlement, representing a routine equity compensation event rather than discretionary market purchases.

Filed: 2026-04-21

CFO Jay D. Martin exercised 3,000 stock options at $333.94 on 04/17/2026, acquiring shares at a significant discount to current trading prices ($525-$527), indicating confidence in company valuation.
Martin sold 2,997 shares (2,255 + 680 + 65) across three tranches at prices ranging from $525.00-$527.72 on the same day as option exercise, suggesting a net sell position after exercising options rather than accumulating equity.
The officer retains 25,963 shares of direct beneficial ownership following transactions, maintaining a substantial equity stake that demonstrates continued confidence despite the net selling activity.
Trading activity executed under Rule 10b5-1(c) plan indicates pre-arranged transactions, reducing concerns about potential market timing or insider trading implications of the concurrent buy-exercise and sell activity.

Filed: 2026-02-11

Kenneth S. Booth, a director of Credit Acceptance Corp (CACC), sold 2,000 shares of the company's common stock on February 9, 2026 at an average price of $508 per share.
Booth still holds a significant position of 22,831.9 shares of CACC common stock directly, indicating he continues to maintain a substantial investment in the company.
Booth also holds employee stock options for an additional 110,000 and 38,000 shares of CACC common stock, suggesting he has a vested interest in the long-term success of the company.

Filed: 2026-02-11

The reporting person, Jonathan Lum, is the Chief Operating Officer of Credit Acceptance Corp and acquired 893 shares of the company's common stock at $0 per share.
Lum's total direct beneficial ownership of Credit Acceptance Corp's common stock increased to 31,608.6 shares following the reported transaction.
Lum also holds 31,500 employee stock options with an exercise price of $333.94 and expiration date of December 30, 2026.

Filed: 2026-02-11

The reporting person, Nicholas J. Elliott, has acquired 2,492 shares of Credit Acceptance Corporation (CACC) common stock, increasing his direct beneficial ownership to 20,897.3 shares.
Elliott also holds an indirect beneficial ownership of 316 shares through the company's 401(k) trust, indicating increased exposure to the company.
Elliott, who holds the position of Chief Transformation Officer, has exercised employee stock options for 13,950 shares, suggesting his alignment with the company's long-term performance.

Filed: 2026-02-11

The reporting person Jay D. Martin, who is the Chief Financial Officer of Credit Acceptance Corp (CACC), exercised 3,000 stock options at $333.94 per share and subsequently sold 4,339.6 shares of common stock at weighted average prices of $513.22 and $511.05.
The insider sale transactions indicate Martin's intention to partially liquidate his CACC equity holdings, which may signal his view on the company's near-term prospects or personal financial needs.
Martin still maintains a sizeable direct ownership of 25,963.1 shares in CACC, suggesting he remains invested in the company's long-term performance.

Filed: 2026-02-06

Kenneth S. Booth, a director of Credit Acceptance Corp (CACC), has sold a significant number of shares in the company over the past few days, totaling 3,219.5 shares.
The transactions were executed at weighted average prices between $508.36 and $513.29 per share, indicating that Booth likely believes the current stock price is fairly valued or potentially overvalued.
Booth still holds a substantial number of shares, with 24,831.9 shares remaining after the reported transactions, suggesting he maintains a significant ownership stake in the company.

Other reports for CREDIT ACCEPTANCE CORP

Quarterly Report Current Report Annual Report

Important Information

AI-generated analysis is for informational purposes only. Always read original SEC filings and consult with qualified professionals before making investment decisions.